A structured research database of 258 Queensland personal injury judgments since 2020. Updated continuously by Roche Legal. Free to search.
Showing 6 cases. Procedural decisions hidden, tick "Include procedural decisions" above to show them.
| Injury category | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
McMillan v Trad
[2026] QSC 108 Damages assessment
Judgment for the plaintiff against the joint defendants in the sum of $8,002.75. The court found the plaintiff suffered only a minor exacerbation of his cervical and lumbar… |
Unemployed | Cervical spine, Lumbar / thoracic spine | MAIA Motor Accident | 42 | $8,003 |
|
Stewart v Metro North Hospital and Health Service
[2025] HCA 34 Appeal
The High Court allowed Mr Stewart's appeal, holding that the trial judge and Court of Appeal had applied the wrong test for reasonableness by balancing only health benefits… |
Unemployed | Brain / head, Head, Abdomen / pelvis +4 | PIPA Medical Negligence | 63 | $5,883,689 |
|
Cabato v Paltridge and Another
[2025] QDC 59 Trial
Judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $73,663.91 after a 25% reduction for contributory negligence. The court found the plaintiff suffered a neck injury, lumbar soft tissue… |
Unemployed | Cervical spine, Lumbar spine, Knees (bilateral) +2 | MAIA Motor Accident | 18 | $73,664 |
|
Ford v Baker & Another
[2025] QDC 43 Damages assessment
Liability was admitted; the trial was confined to quantum. The self-represented plaintiff was found not to be a credible witness and failed to substantiate claims for psychological injury,… |
Unemployed | Ankle / foot, Left lower leg / ankle, Right thigh +1 | MAIA Motor Accident | 57 | $32,808 |
|
Stewart v Metro North Hospital and Health Service
[2024] QCA 225 Appeal
Court of Appeal dismissed Mr Stewart's appeal seeking damages on the basis of independent living, finding no error in the primary judge's conclusion that enhanced care and therapy… |
Unemployed | Brain / head, Brain, Right upper limb +4 | PIPA Medical Negligence | 63 | $2,171,244 |
|
Stewart v Metro North Hospital and Health Service
[2024] QSC 41 Damages assessment
Liability admitted; the dispute was on quantum. The court assessed damages on the basis that the plaintiff would continue to reside in his aged care facility with enhanced… |
Unemployed | Brain / head, Brain, Neurological +3 | PIPA Medical Negligence | 63 | $2,190,505 |
Looking for a specific case? Browse the full case index →, every case in the database on one page, grouped by year.
Roche Legal, Queensland Personal Injury Quantum Database (Web Database, 2026) <https://rochelegal.com.au/quantum-database/>
Use this citation when referring to the resource itself (e.g. in academic articles, annual reports, or media commentary). For a specific case, see the citation block on its individual page.
How this database was built
The dataset draws from published Queensland court judgments from 2020 onwards across the Queensland Court of Appeal, Supreme Court, District Court, Industrial Relations Commission, and tribunals that hear personal-injury matters. Judgments are sourced from publicly available court databases, read against their source PDFs, and entered into a structured database where each case carries its case name, citation, court, year, claim framework, proceeding type, plaintiff age, occupation, outcome, recovery figure, heads-of-damage breakdown, and key procedural attributes.
Sort by plaintiff age, injury, quantum, claim type, and plaintiff outcome. Built from public judgments by Roche Legal for practitioners and prospective claimants.
This database is actively maintained by Sean Roche, Director of Roche Legal. Roche Legal, is a Queensland personal injury firm based in Brisbane. The data on this page is provided as a public resource for journalists, researchers, practitioners and members of the public. Nothing on this page constitutes legal advice.
Connect with Sean on LinkedIn